• home
  • store

ASCD Logo

  • ASCD.org
  • Store
  • Blog
  • Virtual Events
  • Navigate Applications
    • ASCD Activate
    • myTeachSource
    • PD In Focus
    • PD Online
    • Streaming Video
  • Help

    ASCD Customer Service

    Phone
    Monday through Friday
    8:00 a.m.-6:00 p.m.

    1-800-933-ASCD (2723)

    Address
    1703 North Beauregard St.
    Alexandria, VA 22311-1714

    Complete Customer Service Details

  • Log In
ASCD Header Logo
Click to Search
  • Popular Topics
    • Building Racial Justice and Equity
    • Curriculum Design and Lesson Planning
    • Differentiated Instruction
    • Distance Learning
    • Instructional Leadership
    • School Climate and Culture
    • Social-Emotional Learning
    • Understanding by Design
    • Browse All Topics
  • Books & More
    • Browse Books
    • New Books
    • Member Books
    • Quick Reference Guides
    • ASCD Express
    • Newsletters
    • Write for ASCD
    • ASCD Books in Translation
    • White Papers
    • Streaming Videos
    • PD Online Courses
    • PD In Focus
  • Educational Leadership
    • Current Issue
    • Browse EL Archives
    • Digital EL
    • EL Podcast
    • Upcoming Themes
    • Write for EL
    • EL's Tell Us About
  • Membership
    • Benefits
    • Team Memberships
    • Member-Only Webinars
    • Affiliates & More
  • Virtual Events
    • Webinars
    • Symposiums
    • Leadership Summit
    • PreK and K Conference
    • Annual Conference
    • Exhibit with Us
  • Professional Learning
    • On-Site & Virtual PD
    • ASCD Faculty
    • ASCD Staff Speakers
    • ASCD Activate
    • ASCD Regional Partners
    • PD Success Stories
    • PD Request Form
  • Main
  • Archives
  • Write for Express
  • Subscribe

Feedback That Fuels Learning
Janaury 11, 2018 | Volume 13 | Issue 9
Table of Contents 

Share |      

Seven Characteristics (and Six Tools) That Support Meaningful Feedback

Esther Ntuli

It is commonly reported that students do not read or use teacher feedback (Duncan, 2007; Spiller, 2009). Yet, feedback is linked to the development of conscious competence, and is an integral part of engaging and effective learning. It helps students understand the concepts being learned, points out their mistakes, and gives them direction on how to improve or fill the gaps in their learning. Feedback has been found to be "more strongly and consistently related to achievement than any other teaching behavior … this relationship is consistent regardless of grade, socioeconomic status, race, or school setting" (Bellon, Bellon, & Blank, 1991).

Feedback can improve a student's confidence, self-awareness, and enthusiasm for learning. Over the years, I have implemented different types of feedback and completed qualitative research in which students' reflections on feedback were collected and analyzed to find out what students found useful in my feedback. The characteristics of effective feedback shared in this article come from research-based literature review and the qualitative research completed with teacher candidates over the years. The characteristics are ranked from most to least in terms of what would make students want to act on the feedback. In addition, this article shares technology that is useful when providing meaningful feedback.

Table 1. Seven Characteristics of Effective Feedback

Characteristics

Application in the Classroom

Source

1. Constructive.

Try to offer solutions, not just identify problems.

Constructive feedback focuses on the instruction rather than correction.

Hattie & Timperley, 2007

2. Specific

Feedback should point to a specific problem and include a specific example of the solution being recommended.

Spiller, 2009

3. Measurable

Include elements that allow students to know when the feedback has been addressed successfully.

Elements can include well-articulated outcomes within a given time frame. Always follow up with the student before the given time frame lapses.

Hattie & Timperley, 2007; Spiller, 2009

4. Sensitive

Avoid negative language.

Keep recommendations and comments on a positive note. Be mindful of feedback that focuses only on "praise, rewards, and punishment."

Hattie & Timperley, 2007; Poulos and Mahony, 2008

5. Balanced

Point out strengths as well as weaknesses.

Leibold & Schwarz, 2015

6. Applicable

Can the students apply the feedback to similar contexts or similar problems and still achieve the same results?

Students should not view feedback as isolated from other aspects of teaching and learning process.

Shute, 2008; Taras, 2003

7. Not grade focused

When a grade is given, to most students, it is the end of learning.

Effective feedback is not tied to a grade, however; it is tied to descriptors/indicators of high-quality or exemplary work. Use of and reference to rubrics is recommended when giving feedback.

Spiller, 2009; Taras, 2003

Style and Language of Meaningful Feedback

In addition to these seven characteristics, there are other aspects of feedback that I found to be useful, such as style and language used when giving feedback. Spiller (2009) notes that style and language is a very important aspect of feedback and can determine whether students use feedback. Studies suggest that comments on students' task are frequently written in language that makes sense to the teacher but may not be accessible to the students. A study by Duncan (2009) found that most students reported teachers' comments on feedback as difficult to interpret; for instance, instructors used comments and phrases such as

  • Use a more academic style.
  • Deepen analysis of key issues.
  • Sharpen critique.
  • Identify and develop implications.
  • Link theory and practice (Duncan, 2007, pp. 273–274).

Having a clear understanding of the importance of style and language in writing feedback, I now write comments in simple and more descriptive language, which includes specific examples. In addition, I ask students to interpret and reflect on my comments in small groups. This allows for students to gain peer feedback. However, if the feedback was on high-stakes assignments, such as individual assessments, I have student-teacher conferences in which students explain what the feedback is asking them to do.

Using Technology to Deliver Immediate, Elaborative Feedback

In addition to understanding the seven characteristics of effective feedback, it is important for teachers to recognize that today's student expects constant and immediate feedback (Radford, Connaway, Agosto, Cooper, Reuter & Zhou, 2007; Sweeney, 2006). If they don't receive feedback in this manner, their level of frustration with completing tasks mounts. Teachers can use technology to support immediate, elaborative, and real-time feedback. It is important to clarify the meaning of elaborative feedback.

Elaborative Feedback

Elaborative feedback includes an explanation about why an answer is or an action was appropriate, effective, and productive or inappropriate, ineffective, and unproductive (Shute, 2008; Sim, Freiberg, White, Allard, Le Cornu & Carter, 2012). Technology that supports simulations, virtual tours, or field trips makes elaborative feedback more contextualized and applicable. Table 2 summarizes technology that supports delivery of instant, real-time, and elaborative feedback. The technology suggested offers the ability to deliver feedback in different modalities, such as text, images, audioor and video. Technology for elaborative feedback can be integrated with technology for instant feedback. These tools include those that I use and those that are research-based.

Table 2. Technology Tools that Support Instant and Elaborative Feedback

Tools for Instant Feedback

Description and Classroom Application

Socrative.com

Web-based platform that provides teacher-paced assessments and feedback, and student-paced assessments and feedback.

Screencast-O-Matic.com-

Web-based platform that allows users to create videos and share screen recordings. The teacher can record comments in demonstrations provided for the student. This helps with targeting specific feedback.

Vocaroo

Vocaroo allows users to share voice messages online. Teachers can record audio comments and attach to student feedback. This helps to clarify feedback that is difficult to grasp when delivered in text form. I use Vocaroo to deliver feedback (comments or responses) during discussion forums.

Google docs

Allows users to collaborate on digital documents in real time. Teachers can use Google docs to offer real-time feedback in multiple modalities; text, video, graphics, or audio. Teachers should be encouraged to learn how to use most of the Google drive apps (such as Google forms, slides, spreadsheets, drawing, etc.) because they allow instant feedback.

Tools for Elaborative Feedback

Description and Classroom Application

Inspiration

Allows for the teacher to develop feedback in concept maps in which elaboration and connection of concepts are delivered in real time. Allows for visual thinking, in which ideas, words, and concepts are associated with visual images.

Google docs

See explanation in the Tools for Instant Feedback section.

Simulation software

Example:

PhET Interactive Simulations

Allows for the teacher to provide feedback in which modeling of a real phenomenon is possible; students are able to observe and model the concept on the computer.

This article will help novice and seasoned teachers to reflect on how they deliver feedback and how students use their feedback. In addition, they may use some of the tips and tools to improve delivery of feedback to students.

References

Bellon, J.J., Bellon, E.C., & Blank, M.A. (1991). Teaching from a research knowledge base: A development and renewal process. Facsimile edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Duncan, N. (2007). Feed-forward: Improving students' use of tutor comments. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 32(3), 271–283.

Leibold, N., & Schwarz, L.M. (2015). The art of giving online feedback. The Journal of Effective Teaching, 15(1), 34–46.

Poulos, A., & Mahony, M.J. (2008). Effectiveness of feedback: the students' perspective. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 33(2), 143–154.

Race, P. (2001). Using feedback to help students learn. Higher Education Academy. Available at https://www.heacademy.ac.uk/knowledge-hub/using-feedback-help-students-learn

Radford, M. L., Connaway, L. S., Agosto, D. E., Cooper, L. Z., Reuter, K., & Zhou, N. (2007). Behaviors and preferences of digital natives: Informing a research agenda. Proceedings of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 44(1), 1–15.

Shute, V. J. (2008). Focus on formative feedback. Review of educational research, 78(1), 153–189.

Sim,C., Freiberg,J., White, S., Allard, A., Le Cornu, R., & Carter, B. (2012). Using Professional Standards:Assessing work integrated learning in initial teacher education [online resource]. Melbourne: Australian Teaching and Learning Council. Available from http://teacherevidence.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Elaboration-Feedback.pdf

Spiller, D. (2009). Assessment: Feedback to promote student learning. Hamilton, New Zealand: The University of Waikato. Retrieved from http://www.waikato.ac.nz/tdu/pdf/booklets/6_AssessmentFeedback.pdf

Sweeney, R. (2006). Millennial behaviors and demographics. Retrieved from, https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/4fda/fa7b40ada4037374fe4c0c5ad60ee22f5124.pdfBehaviors.dc

Tara, M. (2003). To feedback or not to feedback in student self-assessment. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 28(5), 549–565.

Yorke, M. (2002) Academic failure: A retrospective view from noncompleting students. In Failing Students in Higher Education (eds Peelo, M., & Wareham, T). Maidenhead, UK: SHRE and Open University Press.

Esther Ntuli is an associate professor of instructional technology and an advisor for the master's in elementary education program at Idaho State University.

 

ASCD Express, Vol. 13, No. 9. Copyright 2018 by ASCD. All rights reserved. Visit www.ascd.org/ascdexpress.

ASCD Express

Ideas from the Field

Subscribe to ASCD Express, our free email newsletter, to have practical, actionable strategies and information delivered to your email inbox twice a month.

Subscribe Now

Vote in ASCD's General Membership Election, open April 1-May 15, 2021.Special Announcement

ASCD's 2021 General Membership Election is open April 1–May 15.

Vote now

Meet the candidates

Permissions

ASCD respects intellectual property rights and adheres to the laws governing them. Learn more about our permissions policy and submit your request online.

  • Policies and Requests
  • Electronic File Requests for Students with Print Disabilities
  • Translations Rights
  • Books in Translation

  • ASCD on Facebook (External Link)
  • ASCD on Twitter (External Link)
  • ASCD on Pinterest (External Link)
  • ASCD on Instagram (External Link)
  • ASCD on LinkedIn (External Link)
  • ASCD on Youtube (External Link)

About ASCD

  • About Us
  • Contact Us / Help
  • Governance
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • News & Media
  • Government Relations
  • Whole Child

Get Involved

  • Membership
  • Educator Advocates
  • Affiliates
  • Emerging Leaders
  • Connected Communities
  • Student Chapters
  • Professional Interest Communities

Partner with Us

  • Partners
  • ASCD Job Ramp
  • Advertisers
  • Sponsors & Exhibitors
  • Distributors
ASCD Logo

1703 North Beauregard St.
Alexandria, VA 22311-1714

MISSION: ASCD empowers educators to achieve excellence in learning, teaching, and leading so that every child is healthy, safe, engaged, supported, and challenged.

© 2021 ASCD. All Rights Reserved.