1703 North Beauregard St.
Alexandria, VA 22311-1714
Tel: 1-800-933-ASCD (2723)
8:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. eastern time, Monday through Friday
Local to the D.C. area: 1-703-578-9600
Toll-free from U.S. and Canada: 1-800-933-ASCD (2723)
All other countries: (International Access Code) + 1-703-578-9600
by Deborah L. Voltz, Michele Jean Sims and Betty Nelson
Table of Contents
When we consider standards-based reform, we expect that our students will converge and have similar learning outcomes; however, it is not that simple. We need to account for inclusion, which naturally brings a divergence of student learning styles and challenges. As stated in the Introduction, teachers are being called upon to produce greater similarity in learning outcomes, despite greater diversity in student populations. In this chapter, we will address the second element of the MMECCA framework, the MATERIALS of instruction, or the tangible items, that are used to support instruction and create outcomes for our diverse students.
Materials in the typical general education classroom tend to be limited in scope. Commonly found supplies such as textbooks may be supplemented with student workbooks or worksheets. Sometimes manipulatives and specific multimedia such as number-line sets for math, a globe for social studies, or videos, software, and Internet resources may be used to support learning. These tools typically function as add-ons to the curriculum rather than as an embedded tool for delivering the curriculum. Many schools and districts do not have the funds to purchase these add-on materials. Students in those districts have few options that can be matched to their learning styles or diverse needs. Alternative formats of basic materials can also be provided for students with disabilities, such as Braille texts for students who are blind, large print text for students with low vision, and CDs with audio output for students with dyslexia (Rose, Meyer, & Hitchcock, 2006).
Materials in a Universal Design for Learning (UDL) classroom are different. These materials will be used to give students multiple means of representation of concepts, multiple means of engaging in learning the concepts, and multiple means of expression for students to demonstrate what they have learned. In a UDL classroom, instruction is more flexible and provides accessibility for all students. Teachers who use the principles of UDL in their classroom recognize that instruction does not come as a one-size-fits-all design. For example, digital content can be presented in different ways to meet the learning needs of each student. This content can include adding hyperlinks and glossaries. It might also include graphs, animation, and videos linked within the body of materials to aid understanding and expand content experience to demonstrate a concept (Rose, Meyer, & Hitchcock, 2006). The UDL principles help teachers create classrooms where students can use technologies to move beyond being academic observers. These principles provide a model for self-actuated learning and universal access for all students. Regardless of students' disabilities or differentiated learning styles, every student needs and has the right to access the curriculum (Nelson, 2006). UDL should be part of the initial design of the curriculum, learning environments, and assessments. Pisha and Coyne (2001) call this approach "smart from the start." The following list includes several Web sites that will further your understanding of UDL.
In the Introduction, we discussed some of the founding principles of UDL. It is interesting that this term originated in the field of architecture. The tenets for UDL were created to ensure universal access for individuals of all capabilities. Over time, it became obvious that the designs that were originally intended for individuals with disabilities were helpful to everyone. For example, push bars or lever handles for doors replaced traditional doorknobs. This universal design has become helpful to people without disabilities when they carry large parcels, heavy briefcases, or use cell phones. You can learn more about these tenets at the Center for Universal Design's Web site at http://design.ncsu.edu/cud. When we use UDL principles to build the curriculum and select materials for the classroom, all students will have equal opportunities to learn.
Classroom materials should be designed to follow the basic tenets of UDL—providing students with multiple means of representation, engagement, and expression. It is equally important to select materials that help students retain the information. Learning is not useful if students forget what they have learned. According to Rief (1993), students retain
These statistics remind us that it is important to use multisensory material whenever possible. It may not be feasible to use multisensory material for every lesson you teach. As you vary how you present information in your classroom, students will be more engaged in the learning process. Improved student engagement will result in improved achievement. Figure 2.1 shows examples of multiple ways to engage students in diverse classrooms.
Listening to text read aloud
Using a dictionary
Using a Braille dictionary
Working in areas of student interest
Using a talking dictionary
Listening to and retelling directions
Highlighting key points
Touching words on a word wall
Working with a partner who can help with definitions
Downloading and listening to a podcast on an iPod
Asking and answering questions
Outlining steps to solving a problem
Working alone or in cooperative groups
Using a word processing program
Engaging in a debate
Completing a graphic organizer
Building a model
Participating in a discussion group or book club
Using a talking calculator
Engaging in a discussion
Designing a poster
Using response cards
Participating in a seminar
Giving verbal prompts
Illustrating or taking pictures
Using a game format
Creating a video
Talking through steps
Using blogging or text messaging
From Garguiulo/Metcalf. Teaching in Today's Inclusive Classrooms, 1E. © 2010 Wadsworth, a part of Cengage Learning, Inc. Reproduced by permission. www.cengage.com/permissions.
Reading instruction in the early elementary grades is focused on learning to read. As children graduate into upper elementary and middle school, the focus shifts to reading to learn. Diamond and Moore (1995) discuss the importance of organizing classrooms to foster partnerships and collaboration among diverse students as they talk, listen, read, think, and write. These collaborations include providing students with experiences that allow them to read to learn. In the next section, we will discuss several important areas to be considered with respect to print resources—visual enhancement, cultural plurality, dictionaries, and other aids.
Visually enhanced reading materials can contribute to students' learning experiences. Illustrations with vivid colors and details allow students' imaginations to travel to other times and places (Diamond & Moore, 1995). Exploring the visual details of an environment helps students with reading or language challenges have a better understanding of the context of the reading material. Illustrations also can provide cultural information, open up meaningful literature experiences, and promote dynamic exchanges among diverse students as each person shares his or her interpretation of the story. Visually enhanced reading materials assist struggling readers by
Graphic novels are another print resource to use with struggling readers. These novels are similar to comic books, but they have longer and more complex stories. Graphic novels provide the same benefits as illustrated books and are available in electronic formats.
Ensuring that print materials reflect a spirit of cultural plurality is important to supporting learning in diverse classrooms. The Council on Interracial Books for Children (1978) offers the following guidelines for evaluating children's books for cultural plurality:
When we are aware of these elements, we can provide reading materials to our students that reflect the ideals of culturally responsive instruction. The resources list at the end of this chapter includes sources that can help you select appropriate reading materials.
Electronic dictionaries are a great multimedia support for children with writing challenges. They come in multiple formats, and students can experiment with different versions until they find one that fits their needs. Electronic dictionaries are easier for most students to use than the traditional print version. For diverse students, electronic dictionaries provide helpful features such as auditory assistance for pronunciation or verifying words that students are seeking.
Electronic dictionaries come in formats that are appropriate for young children and mature learners. Many talking dictionaries for young children are illustrated and give them additional learning support. The following list includes online dictionaries that you can explore:
Virtual field trips and tours are great opportunities for students to have content-rich experiences. Teachers can choose a variety of global and national entities to explore, such as NASA, Colonial Williamsburg, the Smithsonian museums, and the Smithsonian National Zoological Park. Some sites offer video streaming observation experiences. For example, the Smithsonian National Zoological Park provides the Pandacam that shows live streaming video of the panda habitat from your choice of two camera views. NASA offers numerous virtual field trips into outer space and across the surface of the earth. Students can follow the daily adventures of scientists and explorers into the far reaches of the earth, watch videos taken from various sites, and e-mail their questions. The Smithsonian museums offer virtual "walking" tours where students can choose what they want to see and walk through as though they are using a video camera. You can explore these virtual tours by using the following links:
Skype and iChat are software applications that allow you to explore virtual opportunities such as bringing guest speakers to classes. These programs open up endless opportunities for students to communicate with experts or children from many countries and cultures. You can link to these services from anywhere in the world. For example, by using virtual docent programs, you can pre-arrange a meeting and connect to wonderful tours, lectures, and question-and-answer sessions. These content-rich experiences give students engaging and valuable opportunities for learning. Let's take a look at how Mr. Hogan uses content-rich experiences in his classroom.
Mr. Hogan is a 5th grade teacher at a school in a low socioeconomic neighborhood. Eighty five percent of the students in the school qualify for free or reduced-priced lunches. Ninety percent of his students are minorities and three students are ELLs. Mr. Hogan is certified in elementary and special education and 45 percent of his students have disabilities, the maximum allowed within education laws and mandates. Mr. Hogan is proud of his students. They have worked well in collaborative learning groups throughout the year with great success.
At the end of the year, Mr. Hogan and his class are completing a unit on ecology in jungle environments, and he decides to schedule a trip for his students to visit the local museum of natural history and meet with the educational team and docent. He is aware that most of his students have never visited the museum due to financial and transportation barriers. Mr. Hogan believes that this trip will be beneficial to his students' life experiences. Unfortunately, the trip was denied due to the school's limited funding.
Mr. Hogan decides to explore the possibility of a virtual field trip. He has heard other teachers talking about these types of trips, and he wonders how it will work in his very diverse classroom. When he contacts the museum, they inform him that they would be glad to help with this project. They tell him that the museum has a Web site with a virtual tour as well as a listing of museums around the country that have virtual habitat exhibits. Mr. Hogan is delighted and proceeds with planning.
The class is divided into five collaborative learning teams for this project. Each collaborative group is a heterogeneous mix of students that is representative of Mr. Hogan's class. Each student is assigned a lead role within his or her group. Each group will make a 10-minute presentation about life in a jungle habitat that includes related study and support materials to be shared with the class. Each group has a film director, a recorder, a wiki director, a spokesperson, and a trip coordinator. Based on each member's strengths and challenges, the following roles are developed, negotiated, and agreed upon:
With technology, there is a place and role for everyone!
Meaningful manipulatives are multisensory tools that are very beneficial for students with diverse learning styles. Earlier in this chapter, we talked about globes and number lines as examples of manipulatives. Working with manipulatives can be more like an integrative brain function when used in motion-centered experiences. TouchMath is a good example of one such set of tools. For this multisensory math program, students begin by using concrete materials such as beans or pieces of cereal to practice counting. Students soon move on to touching points on the manipulated numeral set and other materials that come with the program. Over time, students are able to learn the content by simply using other surfaces for tapping out numbers or using visualizations of previous problem-solving techniques to help them remember math concepts and calculations. For more information, you can log onto
www.touchmath.com for free downloads and videos.
Auditory materials come in an increasing number of formats and can be classified in multiple ways. MP3 players are very popular, pocket-sized devices that play music and other types of audio recordings. Students can use them to play podcasts such as archived recordings from their classes or information transferred from other sites. MP3 players provide flexible access and give students the ability to repeat recordings for clarification and additional information. Many electronic books are available as free downloads in MP3 formats for pleasure or extended learning opportunities.
Amazon offers the Kindle 2, which delivers text-to-speech playback for an extensive list of books, newspapers, and blogs. You can also use this device for your own documents. This device opens up many additional avenues of access for students with reading challenges. The National Instructional Materials Accessibility Standard (NIMAS) requires textbook publishers to produce standard source files that allow their publications to be easily translated into talking books, Braille, and large-print formats. For students who have challenges reading print, alternative formats help them with their reading difficulties. NIMAS was established as part of the reauthorization of Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in 2004. NIMAS provisions apply to students with identified print disabilities who have an Individualized Education Program (IEP). Check out the NIMAS site (http://nimas.cast.org) for more information and program updates. Bookshare is a partner with NIMAS and the U.S. Department of Education and offers many audio book options. You can visit Bookshare at www.bookshare.org.
Today's students have increased exposure to multimedia and pop culture technology resources. Some teachers may question whether there is any value in using these specific resources and other computer- and Internet-based activities. According to the U.S. Department of Education Office of Educational Technology (2004), students' computer skills are far beyond those of their teachers. These students, often referred to as the Millennials, prefer to use the Internet and seek information that is more abundant, accessible, and up-to-date. In a 2004 report, the U.S. Department of Education cited the following facts for today's students:
What is Web 2.0? This term generally refers to a group of new Internet applications that promote the use of, contribution to, and creation of information. Blogs, wikis, podcasting, and social networking are some of the most widely used applications (Churchill, 2007).
The following links are great resources that provide more in-depth information on Web 2.0 applications:
Instructional materials are critical for successful teaching in any classroom, especially in diverse and inclusive classrooms where students' skill levels, learning styles, and interests are more varied. There are many exciting options that can help teachers meet the instructional challenges they face.
In Chapter 3, we will explore other factors related to the context of instruction in diverse and inclusive classrooms.
Bar, C., East, K. A., & Thomas, R. L. (2007). Across cultures: A guide to multicultural literature for children. Santa Barbara, CA: Libraries Unlimited.
Knowles, E., & Smith, M. (2007). Understanding diversity through novels and picture books. Santa Barbara, CA: Libraries Unlimited.
Davis, K. L., Brown, B. G., Liedel-Rice, A., & Soeder, P. (2005). Experiencing diversity through children's multicultural literature. Kappa Delta Pi Record, 41(4), 176–179.
Levin, F. (2007). Encouraging ethical respect through multicultural literature. The Reading Teacher, 61(1), 101–104.
Lowery, R. M., & Sabis-Burns, D. (2007). From borders to bridges: Making cross-cultural connections through multicultural literature. Multicultural Education, 14(4), 50–54.
Teaching Tolerance:www.teachingtolerance.org. This site is a project of the Southern Poverty Law Center. It includes a wealth of information related to culturally responsive instruction. Teachers can request free instructional kits related to topics such as the civil rights movement and the holocaust. This site also includes reviews of multicultural children's literature.
Cooperative Children's Book Center:http://www.education.wisc.edu/ccbc/books/multicultural.asp. This site includes annotated bibliographies of high-quality multicultural children's literature for grades K-12.
Multicultural Children's Literature:http://www.multiculturalchildrenslit.com. This site includes annotated bibliographies of high-quality multicultural children's literature for grades K-12.
Dell, A. G., Newton, D. A., & Petroff, J. G. (2008). Assistive technology in the classroom: Enhancing the school experiences of students with disabilities. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill.
Shelly, G. B., Cashman, T. J., Gunter, R. E., & Gunter, G. A. (2010). Integrating technology and digital media in the classroom. Boston: Thomson.
Bausch, M. E., & Ault, M. J. (2008). Assistive technology implementation plan: A tool for improving outcomes. Teaching Exceptional Children, 41(1), 6–14.
Columbo, M. W., & Columbo, P. D. (2007). Blogging to improve instruction in differentiated science classrooms. Phi Delta Kappan, 89(1), 60–63.
Davis, A., & McGrail, E. (2009). "Proof-revising" with podcasting: Keeping readers in mind as students listen to and rethink their writing. The Reading Teacher, 62(6), 522–529.
Lucking, R. A., Christmann, E. P., & Wighting, M. J. (2009). Podcasts and blogs. Science Scope, 33(3), 64–67.
Putnam, S. M., & Kingsley, T. (2009). The atoms family: Using podcasts to enhance the development of science vocabulary. The Reading Teacher, 63(2), 100–108.
Simpson, C. G., McBride, R., Spencer, V. G., Lowdermilk, J., & Lynch, S. (2009). Assistive technology: Supporting learners in inclusive classrooms. Kappa Delta Pi Record, 45(4), 172–175.
Copyright © 2010 by ASCD. All rights reserved.
No part of this publication—including the drawings, graphs, illustrations, or chapters, except for brief quotations in
critical reviews or articles—may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical,
including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission from ASCD.
Subscribe to ASCD Express, our free e-mail newsletter, to have practical, actionable strategies and information delivered to your e-mail inbox twice a month.
ASCD respects intellectual property rights and adheres to the laws governing them. Learn more about our permissions policy and submit your request online.