HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo

Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
November 1, 2010
Vol. 68
No. 3

Perspectives / Getting a Grip on the Gaps

    premium resources logo

    Premium Resource

    EquityPolicy
    Perspectives / Getting a Grip on the Gaps -thumbnail
      Writing this Perspectives on a Sunday afternoon, I am grappling with the difficulty of closing the myriad gaps depicted in this issue.
      From the nefarious achievement gaps, to the racial isolation in our increasingly segregated schools; from the digital divide that results in kids not having access to computers, to the poverty gulf that results in kids not having homes; from boys' reading difficulties and girls' problems with math, to the disparities among rural, suburban, and urban school needs—these gaps present baffling problems. Even though our authors suggest many practical and even inspiring solutions, the problems themselves sometimes seem as if they will never be conquered entirely. While we address one gap, another springs up.
      In the middle of my reading, I receive two back-to-back, welcome interruptions—phone calls from friends. When they hear what I am up to, each friend quickly offers an opinion about the solution to learning gaps. Neither friend is an educator, and they are on opposite sides politically. But, surprisingly, they both urge me to write about the philanthropy of Mark Zuckerberg, CEO of Facebook, who recently announced a gift of $100 million to the school district of Newark, New Jersey. Each has a different take on this event.
      Friend 1 is delighted with the windfall for Newark (she's from New York). When I demur about the influence of the "billionaire boys club" on education (using Diane Ravitch's term), she says, "Who cares where the money comes from or the motives for giving it? Think of all the good it can do."
      Friend 2 does not believe that the money will make a difference. She scoffs that, once again, money will be "thrown at education without regard to changing attitudes." Citing Bill Cosby as her hero, she believes that an attitude gap—lack of motivation and the will to succeed—is at the heart of most achievement gaps.
      Ah, the attitude gap—or gaps. Talking about any kind of gap brings out polarized opinions. Recently whenWashington Post education writer Jay Matthews (2010) suggested we "forget about the achievement gap," he received about 20 pages of blog responses, some agreeing and some taking him to task. His point is that even when scores for black students in the District of Columbia went up, the public focused on the fact that the gap between blacks and whites had not closed. "We downplay the success of children in one group in favor of comparing their gains to others. … Why not work at raising achievement for every child, in every demographic category, instead of obsessing about the gap?" he writes.
      Another Washington Post op-ed writer sheds light on the psychology of effective interventions. In "Learn to Bridge the Class Divide," Joan C. Williams (2010) warns that many social programs provoke fights between the "have-a-littles" and the "have-nots" and consequently are doomed to fail. "In a country where it is so difficult to pass any social program, it may seem sensible to focus on the neediest. … But politically that has proved shortsighted…" What we need are universal initiatives that bring divided groups together, she suggests.
      In his book As Good as It Gets (2010), education reformer Larry Cuban talks about the difficulty of sustaining even the most innovative reforms, let alone starting universal initiatives. He believes it will be necessary to engage in a concerted effort on many fronts and urges that we combine school improvement with community resources to alleviate the effects of poverty and racial segregation. And not only does he believe in "lifting the floor for the lowest-performing schools," but he also notes that we must "raise the ceiling for the schools in the uppermost tier of achievement."
      From massive infusions of money donated by successful entrepreneurs to an attitude adjustment for each of us, the suggestions abound. Our writers in this issue advocate looking at gaps as opportunities. Among their recommendations are providing equitable resources, high-quality education for all, intensive early literacy programs, well-planned after-school and summer programs, and social and health service coordination for families.
      "Ambitious intervention can make a real difference," Richard E. Nisbett (p. 15) writes, but he speaks also of small interventions that would cost little more than school as usual. "When it comes to reducing the achievement gap, don't think big. Think very big … and very small," he writes.
      Describing the efforts of schools that have successfully reduced gaps, Karin Chenoweth (p. 21) puts it this way, "Do whatever it takes to make sure students learn."
      References

      Cuban, L. (2010). As good as it gets: What school reform brought to Austin. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

      Matthews, J. (2010, August 29). Class struggle: Forget about the achievement gap [blog post]. Retrieved from The Washington Post athttp://voices.washingtonpost.com/class-struggle/2010/08/forget_about_the_achievement_g.html

      Williams, J. C. (2010, September 26). Learn to bridge the class divide.The Washington Post, p. B5

      Marge Scherer has contributed to Educational Leadership.

      Learn More

      ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

      Let us help you put your vision into action.
      Related Articles
      View all
      undefined
      Equity
      The Vital Role of Joy for Educators
      Kimberly Tsai Cawkwell
      4 weeks ago

      undefined
      How Can Schools Support Gender-Diverse Students’ Well-Being?
      Sarah Miles & Samantha T. Selby et al.
      2 months ago

      undefined
      Checking for Anti-Blackness in Our Literacy Work
      Kimberly N. Parker
      2 months ago

      undefined
      Protecting LGBTQ+ Students from Harm
      Craig Aarons-Martin
      2 months ago

      undefined
      Don’t Give Up on Restorative Practice!
      Jamila Dugan
      5 months ago
      Related Articles
      The Vital Role of Joy for Educators
      Kimberly Tsai Cawkwell
      4 weeks ago

      How Can Schools Support Gender-Diverse Students’ Well-Being?
      Sarah Miles & Samantha T. Selby et al.
      2 months ago

      Checking for Anti-Blackness in Our Literacy Work
      Kimberly N. Parker
      2 months ago

      Protecting LGBTQ+ Students from Harm
      Craig Aarons-Martin
      2 months ago

      Don’t Give Up on Restorative Practice!
      Jamila Dugan
      5 months ago
      From our issue
      Product cover image 111031.jpg
      Closing Opportunity Gaps
      Go To Publication