HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo

Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
September 21, 2020
ASCD Blog

Unpacking Unconscious Bias in Grading: Readers React

author avatar
    Equity
    Unpacking Unconscious Bias in Grading: Readers React Thumbnail
      One of the most-viewed articles in Educational Leadership’s September issue is an interview on anti-racist grading with Cornelius Minor, a lead staff developer with the Teachers College Reading and Writing Project. In response to questions from EL’s Sarah McKibben, Minor cautions that equitable, learning-centered grading is not something educators can just pick up from an “activity playbook.” Instead, it starts with “examining the biases that [we] bring into schools and the discriminatory ideologies and structures that lead to” harmful instructional practices.
      Minor identifies three pernicious educator ideologies that often warp grading, particularly with respect to students of color: the expectation of what students should know (as opposed to working with students on the basis of what they do know); the presumption of transactional gratitude (holding that students have an unspoken debt to teachers); and the weighing of deservedness (when student proficiency is conflated with behavior or compliance). By uprooting these interiorized perspectives, Minor suggests, educators can begin to focus on the real purposes of grading—helping kids grow and meet desired learning outcomes.
      Minor’s thoughts on this topic have generated some strong responses from our readers, including urgent calls for educators to re-examine their presumptions in the new school year. Here’s a selection:  
      As you can see, the piece has clearly struck a chord. Minor makes some incisive points on classroom bias in a back-to-school season in which issues of racial justice are paramount. And, perhaps more important, he provides a compelling framework for educators to challenge—and adjust—potentially maladaptive thinking and practices. How might Minor’s ideas inform your approach this school year or shape professional- learning discussions in your school? Be sure to check out the complete interview and other stories on grading reform in EL’s September issue.    
      About the author
      Anthony Rebora is the editor in chief of Educational Leadership.

      Anthony Rebora is the chief content officer for ISTE+ASCD, overseeing publications and content development across all platforms.

      Previously, he was the editor in chief of Educational Leadership, ASCD's flagship magazine, and led content development for the association's fast-evolving digital outlets.

      Under his leadership, Educational Leadership won numerous awards for editorial excellence, increased the breadth of its coverage and contributors, and greatly expanded its online reach.

      He was formerly a managing editor at Education Week, where he oversaw coverage of teachers and teaching policy, and played a key role in online editorial strategy. He has written and developed impactful content on a wide range of key K-12 education topics, including professional learning, school leadership and equity.

      As a content developer, his foremost goals are to empower diverse educator voices and raise awareness of critical issues and solutions in education.

      Learn More

      ASCD is dedicated to professional growth and well-being.

      Let's put your vision into action.
      Related Blogs
      View all
      undefined
      Equity
      Behind the Book: The Antiracist Roadmap to Educational Equity
      Emma Hii
      1 month ago

      undefined
      Q&A: Bettina Love on Centering Black Excellence
      Jessica Comola
      1 month ago

      undefined
      Multilingual Newcomers Need More Than Academic Instruction
      Rebecca L. Olsen
      1 month ago

      undefined
      4 Shifts to Celebrate Language Diversity 
      Lorena Germán
      2 months ago

      undefined
      Ditching School Diet Culture
      Caitlin O'Connor
      2 months ago
      Related Blogs
      Behind the Book: The Antiracist Roadmap to Educational Equity
      Emma Hii
      1 month ago

      Q&A: Bettina Love on Centering Black Excellence
      Jessica Comola
      1 month ago

      Multilingual Newcomers Need More Than Academic Instruction
      Rebecca L. Olsen
      1 month ago

      4 Shifts to Celebrate Language Diversity 
      Lorena Germán
      2 months ago

      Ditching School Diet Culture
      Caitlin O'Connor
      2 months ago